ADVERTISING
 
Wednesday, April 8   Sign in or Register
 
Evangelical Focus
 

 
ADVERTISING
 
 
FOLLOW US ON
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Google +
  • Instagram
  • Soundcloud
 

Newsletter
Newsletter, sign up to receive all our News by email.
 

POLL
Coronavirus
Which of these online initiatives should churches prioritise?






SEE MORE POLLS
 

 
TOP 10 MOST VIEWED



Joel Forster
 

Christian fake news? The story of the atheist doctor in Lombardy

Many have shared a heartwarming coronavirus testimony from Italy. But there are at least five elements that should make us doubt about its authenticity.

NEWS DESK AUTHOR Joel Forster VALENCIA 26 MARCH 2020 13:30 h GMT+1
Capture of the story of a doctor in Lombardy shared in a Whatsapp message.

Whatsapp and other instant messaging applications are very useful in these times of coronavirus crisis. Through these tools we keep in touch with family, friends and members of our local church.



But - is it the best source for news? Experience shows us that forwarded messages we get on our phone often lead us to confusion. Whenever there are doubts, we should apply a series of authenticity filters like those we suggest at the end of this article.



 



THE ITALIAN DOCTOR AND THE OLD PASTOR



One of the news that has been broadly shared in Christian circles has been a story under the title: “Testimony of Iulian Urban, 38 years old. He is a doctor in Lombardy”.



It tells the testimony of a medical doctor who decides to return to the Christian faith after meeting a 75 years old pastor. The man is a patient who uses his time in hospital to read the Bible to other patients and care about them, bringing peace, comfort and faith even to the medical staff, who used to have atheist convictions.



This story has already been translated to several languages (including Italian, English, Spanish, French) and read by thousands in Europe and Latin America. Even some websites have published it.



But the story may be a case of false news. After doing some research, we conclude that there are at least 5 evidences that lead to this conclusion.



1. The photo. The image of the doctor that goes with the testimony, shared by many, has most probably been downloaded from the internet. Bored Panda includes the photo of the man in a gallery of “34 Heartbreaking pics of overworked doctors…”. The website links to the original source of the photo: Nicola Sgarbi, who is, yes, an Italian medical doctor. Nicola posted the photo on his Facebook profile on 14th March, saying he took the selfie “after 13 hours in the ICU”. But he does not mention God nor does he share a testimony of conversion to the Christian faith.



2. The original source of the testimony. “Testimony via Gianni Giardinelli” is what can be read at the bottom of the text in some of the earliest versions. A search on the internet shows that Gianni Giardinelli is a French actor of Italian origin, living in Paris. On his social media accounts, there is no trace of this testimony. Could the source mentioned be another person with the same name? Yes, but there seem to be no ways of contacting this person.



3. The name of the doctor. “Iulian” and “Urban” are not an Italian name and surname, but Romanian. Of course the doctor of the story could be a Romanian health worker working in Italy, but this is not the case. Emanuel Contac, a theologian in Bucharest has confirmed to us that Iulian Urban is the person who first shared the testimony in Romania, which situates the origin of the story in that country. Urban is not a physician but a lawyer who was a Member of the Romanian Senate between 2008-2012. He has thousands of followers on social media, which would help to explain why the story became viral in the first place.



But there is something else. Emanuel Contac himself contacted with Iulian Urban to learn more details about the story. The answer of the politician in a series of private messages was always that the Italian doctor did not want to be named and had every right to remain anonymous, having his privacy respected. After more than a dozen of messages, writes Emanuel via email, “I decided not to pursue this issue further. The conversation was an exercise in futility and absurd thought”.



4. The variations of the story. Another reason that should make us feel suspicious is that there are several versions of the testimony. Some versions do not speak of a pastor but of a priest. The twist can be traced back to the Facebook page “Ortodoxia Tinerilor”, also based in Romania, which published the story 3 times in two days - 18th and 19th March. The second time, it spoke of a pastor, but the first and third posts referred to a priest. The most popular version was that of the priest, with more than 4,000 shares.



 



Facebook capture.



5. The opinion of Christians in Italy. Finally, there is the question of what Christian leaders in Italy think of this story. We asked a member of the Italian Evangelical Alliance board, who then contacted evangelical pastors of denominations such as the Assemblies of God and the Romanian Churches in Italy. They all agreed, we were told, that the testimony “is not reliable”.



All of these elements point to the conclusion that the story about the doctor of Lombardia is an example of false news.



Is there a chance that there might be some truth in the story and that the testimony was heavily distorted as it was shared? Yes, this is of course a possibility. It could be that what we read on our phone is a version of a version… of a true story. But even if that was the case, should we pay attention and share information which we know includes several untrue aspects?



 



HOW TO IDENTIFY A FAKE NEWS STORY



A story that comes to us in the form of a Whatsapp message should always go through a series of filters which help us assess its authenticity. These are some questions that may help:



- Does the person who is forwarding this information to us know the origin of the message?



- Does the information have a link to more information? If so, does the website/source deserve our trust?



- Does the story come with the name of the author? Is there any chance to confirm that this person is who he/she says he is?



- Has the story a date in which it was written?



- How is the writing? Does it give detailed and verifiable data? Does it include sensationalist elements?



- Are there other media who have published this story?



- Are there reasons to think that the author of this story was seeking to provoke a certain reaction in the people who read it?


 

 


0
COMMENTS

    If you want to comment, or

 



 
 
YOUR ARE AT: - - - Christian fake news? The story of the atheist doctor in Lombardy
 
ADVERTISING
 
 
 
AUDIOS Audios
 
Jonathan Tame: Economy, looking back at the decade Jonathan Tame: Economy, looking back at the decade

The Director of the Jubilee Centre (Cambridge) analyses the impact of the financial crises on families, and the future of the workplace in a connected world, from a Christian perspective.

 
Jim Memory: Europe, looking back at the decade Jim Memory: Europe, looking back at the decade

Jim Memory analyses the main issues that have changed Europe in the 2010-2019 decade. How should Christians live in a continent that has lost its soul?

 
Julia Doxat-Purser: 25 years of EEA office in Brussels Julia Doxat-Purser: 25 years of EEA office in Brussels

An interview with the socio-political representative of the European Evangelical Alliance about how evangelical Christians work at the heart of the European Union.

 
Ruth Valerio: A lifestyle that cares about creation Ruth Valerio: A lifestyle that cares about creation

Are Christians called to make a difference in environmental care? What has creation care to do with "loving our neighbours"? An interview with the Global Advocacy and Influencing Director of Tearfund.

 
PICTURES Pictures
 
Photos: European Week of Prayer Photos: European Week of Prayer

Christians joined the Evangelical Alliance Week of Prayer in dozens of European cities as local churches came together to worship God. 

 
Photos: Students at ‘Revive Europe’ Photos: Students at ‘Revive Europe’

Photos of the student conference that brought together 3,000 European Christians in Germany. ‘Revive our hearts, revive our universities, revive Europe’.

 
VIDEO Video
 
How should Christ's love inform your parenting of teenagers? How should Christ's love inform your parenting of teenagers?

Dave Patty shares about the notion of parenting children on God’s behalf.

 
What is a prayer meeting? What is a prayer meeting?

“Prayer is like a fire. One spark that someone prays should ignite a passion in someone else”. Mike Betts leads the network of churches Relational Mission.

 
Video: Highlights of ‘Revive Europe’ Video: Highlights of ‘Revive Europe’

A video summary of the student conference that gathered 3,000 in Karlsruhe, Germany. 6 days in 6 minutes.

 
 
Follow us on Soundcloud
Follow us on YouTube
 
 
WE RECOMMEND
 
PARTNERS
 

 
AEE
EVANGELICAL FOCUS belongs to Areópago Protestante, linked to the Spanish Evangelical Alliance (AEE). AEE is member of the European
Evangelical Alliance and World Evangelical Alliance.
 

Opinions expressed are those of their respective contributors and do not necessarily represent the views of Evangelical Focus.